I have a confession. I used to hate history. I vividly remember taking an American history class my sophomore year in University and claiming that it's ridiculous we are required to learn history. What's done is done, and we should focus on the now or the future instead of the past. Oh dear me, how arrogantly ignorant I must have sounded. I hate to admit how close minded I was, but I am also encouraged to see how much I've grown.
History shapes everything. It allows us to understand why people feel the way they do. It reveals the driving motive of so many actions, and enables us to hold more educated opinions on current issues.
Nothing brings this truth closer to home for me right now than the conflict between Israel and the Palestinian territories. You get a different opinion depending on who you ask and how far back you go in time--which part of history you choose to narrow in on.
Sure, it seems simple enough to say that Israel is building a wall around the Palestinian territories to keep out suicide bombers who are dangerous to everyone.
Sure, I spoke with Israelis who make simple claims that they are willing to give Palestinians the Gaza Strip and the West Bank but Palestinians want more--they want it all--and that's why Israel must defend itself.
However, jump back to 1967 when Israel was yet to become a state. At that time, it was actually Palestinians whose land was taken from them. They claim they are only fighting for the land that was always theirs, that they were pushed from when forced to become refugees.
I spoke with a Palestinian who now lives in Jordan. In so many words, she said she didn't care where the Jewish people lived, that wasn't her business, as long as they didn't live where her family used to. As long as they left the land that belonged to her bloodline. If only it were that simple.
Let's take a complete turn and look at European history and the Holocaust. The displacement of Jews after this atrocious genocide nearly masks the injustice caused to the Palestinians. It makes sense that we wanted to set up a state for Jewish people, a place they could call their own. It also makes sense that it would be on the land that is significant to their history for thousands of years. But it doesn't really make sense that others living there are forced to step aside and just give it up.
I'm simplifying the issue. I'm not trying to make it a history lesson. I'm just trying to show that when I left Israel, I felt I had much more of a grasp on what's going on. But then I went to Jordan where I heard a completely different side of the story.
The mind boggling part is that they are both true. It's not that anyone is deliberately making "their side" up. It's simply that people are focusing on the chunk of history relevant to their emotions and pain and when the issue is as personal as this one, it's so hard to look at the entire picture--a picture that is complicated and messy, hurtful and embarrassing.
I cried for the Jews in Israel. I sat inside the Holocaust museum and just let my heart feel the pain of what happened.
I cried for the Palestinians in Jordan. I sat inside a living room drinking tea with a family and letting my heart feel the pain of their loss.
If it were true that history doesn't matter, that what's done is done, the pain I witnessed wouldn't exist and let me tell you, it surely does.
History becomes tangible when its effects are still rippling today, causing some people to die in the current. Without knowledge of history, there is no understanding, and without understanding, how can there be love?